I agree with the idea that for intensive appliations such as Maya and AutoCad that a mix of TS and VDI is a very strong solution. Use the TS for general applications to gain the efficiency of the shared servers and use VDI for apps that require more resources and/or have compatibility/support issues.
I also like Provision Server to PC hardware because you get the best of both worlds-local graphics performance and compatibility with centralized mamangment.
In *some* cases I think Provisioning Server to PC is a better thin client!!
Steve Greenberg
Thin Client Computing
34522 N.
(602) 432-8649
steveg@thinclient.net
From: thin-bounce@freelists.org [mailto:thin-bounce@freelists.org] On Behalf Of Rick Mack
Sent: Wednesday, March 11, 2009 4:18 AM
To: thin@freelists.org
Subject: [THIN] Re: thin client deployment in a school
Hi Puneet,
I'm the greatest fan of terminal services around and I've done lots of successful school terminal server rollouts. I've even got our developers to produce freeware utilities so you can run stuff like AutoCAD multi-user on terminal services.
But 150 students isn't a lot of students and stuff like Maya, 3D Max etc is going to need some really hefty compute power (read GPUs) for rendering that you're not going to get in a shared environment, either terminal services or VDI. By all means use thin clients and put the compute power back in the computer room but don't even think about doing this stuff on either a pure terminals ervices or VDI solution unless you like pain.
Worst case I'd be tempted to go for a mix of VDI and PC blades and since the apps aren't OpenGL you're going to have to seriously consider using something like HP's RGS protocol which can deliver 3D applications, multimedia etc. I'd use HP's T5730 thin clients provided you can get a good price and you'll have a brilliant 3D application delivery system. The only gotcha with RGS is that the video resolution and colour depth are limited to the maximum console video capabilities. That means VMware is out (1180x885) for VDI and you're left with something like Hyper-V (1600x1200) or maybe some other Xen-based hypervisor to get decent screen resolution.
Of course if we're talking PC blades it wouldn't be fair not to mention Panologic and Teradici in particular because their solutions are pretty darn good for 3D applications (and just about anything else).
Citrix provisioning server has a possible place but if you're using PC blades there may be less expensive solutions out there.
regards,
Rick
--
Ulrich Mack
Quest Software
Provision Networks Division
On Thu, Mar 5, 2009 at 7:36 PM, Puneet Goel <g.puneet@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi,
I have to deply thin client in a school for around 150 students. They
will be working on advanced IT apps like 3D Max, Maya, Autocad,
Photoshop, Oracle, SQL.
can anyone guide me in finalizing server requirements for them.
thanks
************************************************
For Archives, RSS, to Unsubscribe, Subscribe or
set Digest or Vacation mode use the below link:
http://www.freelists.org/list/thin
Follow ThinList on Twitter
http://twitter.com/thinlist
Thin List discussion is now available in blog format at:
http://thinmaillist.blogspot.com
Thinlist MOBILE Feed
http://thinlist.net/mobile
************************************************
No comments:
Post a Comment